A Keepsake Letter – A Message From Susan
When you first read this title, you may have thought that I was referring to my great great grandmother Susan Stanbrough Hine on my mother’s father’s side of the family. Although I do in fact have a letter (two letters now) from her that I intend to share later on, I am writing about a different ancestor named Susan. This one is Susan Jackson Phenice, my great great great grandmother on my mother’s mother’s side of the family. Her son was Samuel Phenice who fought in the Civil War. Her grandson was H. C. Phenice, who was the Phenice that brought the Phenice name to Louisiana.
And H. C didn’t just have one grandmother with the name of Susan – both of his grandmothers were named Susan. I’m pretty sure his other grandmother’s name was Susan Penrod Foster. ( Correction – now I am absolutely sure that his other grandmother was not another Susan. Her name was Anne Magdaleen Milliron Foster.) I’m not certain about that other Susan, so in the meantime we will look at Susan Jackson Phenice and the letter that she wrote to us.
Well, it wasn’t actually written to us, but we can take some of her sentiments to heart. It was written on April 16, 1877, to her daughter-in-law Ida Fitzgerald Phenice, who was married to son Abraham Phenice. They had a small daughter named Emma Maud (maud in the letter) who was about three years old at the time. Susan talks about some of her children, though she doesn’t mention Samuel by name.
Let’s take a look at that letter now. I have spent some time cleaning up the scan of the letter so it would be more legible. But I will go ahead and transcribe it for you.
First page –
April the 16, 1877
Well Dear Ida I suppose you think/ by this I dont intend to write to/ [indecipherable words] I should/ and would have writen before but/ when I heard from when ever you/ wrote to Abram (her son Abraham) in particular after/ I was informed of your condition/ I sympathize with you very much/ for I have experienced such times/ but be of good cheer and in good heart/ keep up your courage and dont/ dispare for he that puts on the/ burden – can take it of again all/ that we must do is to look to Jesus/ and he will help in times of need/ how soon do you expect to be/ back to work you could be here/ before that time we would all/ (continued on page 2)
Page 2 –
feel better satisfied to be/ together there none of us can count/ on many years at the longest/ and why not be with each/ other while we are here it is the Joy of my heart when the children / comes home you wanted to know/ if Abe was as good a son as he was a husband/ he is I am/ very proud of him and/ all the rest but better boys than/him and harper is cant be/ found every day. I expect we will/ move to petrolia this week or the/ first of next if you come out here you/ will be handy the catholic church/ Just quit(e) a short distance from where/ our house is and the methodist/ church is handy too I think Willams (another son)/ family will be here soon. Just as/ soon as we leave the house Daughter/ Kate will be quite handy and [blob] (continued on page 3)
Page 3 –
That Dear little boy of/ yours (Abe) went to petrolia (in Butler County, Pennsylvania) to work/ this morning as lively as a cricket/ he is in good heart work is/ plenty they can get all they do/ can do all they have to do is to work/ and they will money no doubt/
well Ida I have nothing of/ importance to write to you/ as Abe writes so often he tells you/ all the news the family is/ all well I dont feel very rugged to day my head aches/ considerable but it will soon/ be better I am going to make/ myself some coffee and that/ will straiten me out I suppose/ I trouble myself to much about/ moving the boys scolds me/ for it that Abe and Harper they think I have no need to worrie (continued on page 4)
Ida Dear remember me in/ your prayers that I may obtain/ a home in heaven Oh that/ we all will meet at the right of god/ and walk hand in hand in/ the new Jerusalem where there/ is no sickness nor sorrow all is/ peace and happiness let us try to/ meet the Dear ones gone before us/
I will stop by bidding/ you good by for a while/ kiss maud for me this is her/
from your mother
Susan Phenice
the family all sends their love/ to you and maud
(end of letter)
Isn’t that a sweet keepsake to have? I remember Mama having a copy of it in her collection of family information. I don’t know how she got it. Maybe her cousins provided her with the copy. I’m grateful to whoever did.
My favorite part of the letter is from page 2 when she says “it is the Joy of my heart when the children comes home.” I’ve even used it as cousin bait. That is a term I’ve read in genealogy circles (trust me, they’re out there) that doesn’t sound very sweet. It just means a little enticing tidbit that you share with a cousin to tempt them into responding to you. I did that with cousin Mona and it worked! I edited it to fit my message by altering her quote to “It is the Joy of my heart when the children come together.” I think it has the same meaning and I’m sure Grandma Susan would approve of my intent.
And if I was actually having a conversation with ol’ Susan, I’d also like to ask her about “the Dear ones gone before us.” Because I don’t know the names of her parents or grandparents. I do know that she was born in Somerset County, Pennsylvania, in 1806, and then she died in Petrolia two years after she wrote this letter. And it’s obvious from her writing that she has strong beliefs and that she really cherished her family. Good things to know.

















George was born in Hamilton county in 1846 (and died in 1919) and showed up with the family there through the 1870 census. Then the family shows up in Boone County in the 1880 census. They stayed there until they moved to Louisiana in 1894. In the meantime the kids were going to school, as can be evidenced by this certificate that Addie received for attendance that was dated June 4, 1892.














Here is a photo of me with Papi when I was three years old. It sure does look like he may have been singing in my ear! He assured me that he was singing the “Yo! Ho!” song to me. “What?” I asked, “That song wasn’t written until our Reunions Adventure. This picture was taken way before that.”