Myrtle Sings Lost In a Fog
You’ll have to thank cousin Toni for the blog I’m writing this week. On Facebook she shared a blog that I wrote nine years ago. In that post you get to hear our grandmother Myrtle Phenice Bucklin (We called her Grandma.) sing a few songs. The recordings were from 1944 when her brother Sylvan was experimenting with his newfangled cutting needle for recording on those old discs. It was probably at the family home in Hathaway, Louisiana. The post was part of a series I wrote on my family about the musical influences through the years. Of course I had to do one on Grandma, she was always singing and playing the piano or organ.
When Toni shared that post, some of the cousins commented on how nice it was to have those recordings. I had to agree. It’s amazing to hear songs that were recorded in 1944 when she was just 36 years old or so. It made me look to see if there were some other songs that I had from back then that I hadn’t shared. I found one! It’s not the greatest quality by far. Her singing almost gets lost in the fog of all the static and crackling on the old recording. But there is definitely a wonderful charm about the old song sung by our Myrtle.
It sounds like something you would hear in an old timey movie where someone was waiting in the parlor and listening to something on an old gramophone player. She is singing in a high register, though it sounds like she has no problem with this. It’s definitely higher than she sang on the other recordings. It made me wonder for a while if it was possibly her mother Daisy Keys Phenice singing it. But once I compared their singing from other recordings, I was pretty sure it was Myrtle. Unless the recording of Daisy is a poor representation of her singing abilities, she didn’t seem to have the same pitch control that her daughter Myrtle had.
The song is called “Lost In a Fog” and it was introduced in the 1934 movie “Have a Heart.” It was written by Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh. It has been recorded by several artist over the years. In this recording Myrtle sings an introduction that I haven’t seen on the famous ones I found. I can’t make out the words to the introduction because of the low quality of the recording. The introduction occurs in the first thirty seconds of the song, and it is followed by the lyrics that are more commonly known:
Like a ship at sea
I’m just lost in a fog.
My mind is hazy;
My thoughts are blue.
Guess I’ll always be
kinda lost in a fog without you.
Waiting night and day
like a bump on a log.
I’m going crazy;
What can I do?
Help me find my way
’cause I’m lost in a fog without you.
It was sunny every day.
The sky was fair above,
but you took the light away
the day you took your love.
Only fools like me
could be tossed in a fog.
I’ve got a heartache;
I never knew
Guess I’ll always be
Kinda lost in a fog without you
Sadly, you will not be able to hear the last line of text that I’ve typed here. That’s because when the recording gets to “Guess I’ll always be kinda lost in a fog without you,” all you hear is “Guess I’ll alw lawl lawl…” It’s a reminder of what happens to those records if you didn’t take extra care of them. A little scratch and it would repeat would repeat would repeat would repeat until you had a chance to knock it or gently pick up the needle and place it past the offending scratch!
Like I said, it’s not the best recording. But it is another recording from long, long ago! How can you not love that?
Click on this link for the song: Lost In a Fog















